Are the W5500 products we have original or fake ?
Ethernet Chips
Attachments
-
W5500.png
- W5500
No replies yet. Be the first to reply.
Join the discussion.
Ethernet Chips
No replies yet. Be the first to reply.
Join the discussion.
Share projects and connect with makers.
Joined before the site update? first.
New to WIZnet Makers?
We sent a verification link to your address. Open it to activate your account, then log in.
Accounts from this email provider are reviewed by an administrator after verification. Approval usually takes one business day.
Already have an account?
Enter your email address. If it belongs to an account, we'll send a link to set a new password. Members who joined before the site update use this to set their password.
If an account uses that address, we sent a link to set a new password. The link works once and expires in 30 minutes.
Know your password?
Need an account?
RE: Are the W5500 products we have original or fake ?
by lawrence WIZnet ·
Hi Huseyin_Ozdil,
Thank you for the detailed description and for sharing the comparison photos. Placing the two parts side by side really helps us understand the situation accurately.
To be upfront: we cannot confirm authenticity from photographs alone. Looking at your images, the top-side markings on both chips (the WIZnet logo, the W5500 part number, the trace code, and the YYWW date code) fall within the normal range.
We also noticed that the backside surface texture and corner markings differ between the two parts. However, this difference alone is not enough to conclude that a part is counterfeit. Lots produced at different times can legitimately differ in backside appearance, because the assembly subcontractor, mold compound, and laser-marking equipment can change between production runs — so genuine parts from different periods may also show backside variation.
For that reason, the more important signal here is the "instability" you described in operation, rather than the external appearance. To investigate this properly, it would help if you could provide the following so we can verify through our official process:
1. The full trace/lot code printed on the unstable parts (in addition to DQK580 in the photo, if there are other codes, please include them).
2. The name of the supplier (local distributor) and the purchase date — an invoice or purchase record would be helpful if available.
3. Whether you can send samples for analysis — sending an unstable part would give us the most accurate result.
4. Detailed description of the unstable behavior you found from unstable IC - Link issue, SPI access issue, TCP/UDP communication issue, reset issue, etc.
By cross-checking the trace code against our production and shipment records, we can do a first-level verification of where the part originated. If we receive samples, we can go further with electrical/parametric measurement and package/die comparison to determine both authenticity and the root cause of the instability.
As context, the 2020–2023 period coincided with the global semiconductor shortage, when quality variation in parts sourced through non-authorized channels was unusually common. Going forward, where possible, we would recommend purchasing through authorized channels such as DigiKey, Mouser, or WIZnet's official regional distributors.
Please reply to lawrence@wiznet.io once you have the information and samples ready, and we will help you promptly. Thank you.
Best regards,
Lawrence